This post (from Joseph Romm) on Climate Progress asks what economists brings to the table when it comes to fight climate change (in a rather rude way, I must say). I think the entire post is ‘under the belt’ with a lot of claims that are not justified. Romm touches on both the green jobs debate (more here) and the use of cost-benefit analysis when it comes to climate issues. Anyway, Joseph Romm’s post has ignited debate over on Environmental Economics:
- I don’t find this post at Climate Progress helpfull at all
- Joe Romm misses the point
- Dano(?) comments
Joseph Romm is not done yet, however; Voodoo economists, Part 2 (and more is coming our way). John Whitehead has no comment.
I don’t know if Joseph Romm is drawing himself, but he lets a very funny cartoon acompany his initial post; I just had to include it myself:
UPDATE: More comments to Mr. Romm:
- The Strange Case of Joe Romm (A brilliant response from John Fleck!)
- More on the Stavins quote
Hattip: Env-econ
Tags: cartoon, climate change, Climate Progress, Environmental Economics, green jobs, John Fleck, John Whitehead
January 14, 2009 at 10:26 am
[…] Kvams Opinions, thoughts and feelings on books, music, economics, and life. « Do economists help fight climate change? […]
January 18, 2009 at 11:18 pm
[…] Romm on Rhetoric & the Climate By kvams Even though he has showed a negative attitued towards economists, Joe Romm has a lot of interesting posts on his blog, Climate Progess. Today, I stumbled over some […]
February 16, 2009 at 12:17 pm
[…] I am sorry that Joe Romm does not take the opportunity to argue in a polite manner with convincing and coherent writing when he commands one of the most important climate blogs nowadays, but sees it necessary to sprinkle it with cheap characteristics and speculative halftruths as he does in his voodoo economics series, for example (Do Econmists Help Fight Climate Change?). […]
February 21, 2009 at 10:37 pm
[…] vs. Environmentalists By kvams The voodoo climate-economics debate continues. Common Tragedies calls the bashing of economists on Climate Progress evidenceless and […]
February 25, 2009 at 2:36 pm
[…] Do economists help fight climate change? Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Green Party On The Stim PlanFull Funding of the Green Jobs Act has a chance on the Senate floor tomorrow!Green Jobs = Good for the Environment, Bad for Women?Looking for a Green Job? […]